RWA Series — The Spectrum of Tokenization: From Traditional to Fully On-Chain

This post is part of our in-depth series on Real World Asset (RWA) tokenization. If you missed the first post, where we introduced the concept of tokenizing physical assets and its transformative impact on industries like sustainable infrastructures and intellectual property, you can read it here.

This post will explore the spectrum of tokenization models and their relevance across various industries, from traditional finance to fully on-chain systems. As the tokenization landscape continues to evolve, businesses need to understand where they fit along this spectrum and how they can leverage blockchain technology for maximum impact.

Introduction

Tokenization has evolved into one of the most transformative financial technologies, redefining the way assets are owned, transferred, and managed. It began with cryptocurrencies but has rapidly expanded into real-world applications, including real estate, intellectual property, and commodities. By representing real-world assets as tokens on a blockchain, tokenization democratizes access to previously illiquid or exclusive markets, providing new investment opportunities for a wider range of participants.

However, tokenization is no longer a binary concept. It exists along a dynamic spectrum that ranges from off-chain models with minimal blockchain involvement to fully decentralized systems. This post examines the spectrum of tokenization, discusses how businesses can leverage different models across industries, and highlights where erable° fits into this fast-evolving space.

Key Concepts

1. Understanding the Spectrum of Tokenization

As tokenization matures, it is important to recognize that assets can be digitized to varying degrees. These models represent different points along the spectrum, each offering unique benefits, challenges, and applications across industries.

Model 1: Status Quo

• In this traditional model, assets like real estate or bonds are not tokenized, and all transactions occur entirely off-chain. Legal agreements, ownership, and value transfer are handled by intermediaries such as brokers, lawyers, or financial institutions. This model is common in industries with little to no blockchain adoption.

Model 2: On-Chain Representation

• Assets are still controlled off-chain, but their digital representations are tokenized on a blockchain. Ownership and value transfer happen through traditional systems, while tokens merely reflect off-chain agreements.
• Benefits:
• Increases transparency by recording asset representation on-chain.
• Reduces entry barriers for investors by fractionalizing high-value assets like real estate and bonds.
• Challenges:
• Limited automation since most processes remain off-chain.
• Regulatory concerns may persist, as ownership is still governed by off-chain agreements.

Model 3: On-Chain Integration

• In this model, blockchain facilitates some elements of ownership and value transfer, while other aspects remain off-chain. For instance, real estate-backed loans might be tokenized, but ownership rights are enforced traditionally. Smart contracts execute key functions like payments or collateralization, enabling partial automation.
• Benefits:
• Increases operational efficiency through smart contracts.
• Provides better liquidity and access to assets like real estate or loans through fractional ownership.
• Challenges:
• Full integration with legal and regulatory frameworks is still lacking.
• Limited scalability for some assets due to reliance on off-chain enforcement.

Model 4: On-Chain Enforcement

• This model allows blockchain technology to enforce ownership rights. Legal frameworks recognize and uphold tokenized assets as legally binding. A small number of jurisdictions now accept tokenized securities or property rights, offering fully enforceable ownership without relying on off-chain agreements.
• Benefits:
• Ownership and transactions are fully automated through smart contracts.
• Reduces reliance on traditional intermediaries, improving efficiency and lowering costs.
• Challenges:
• Regulatory acceptance is limited to a few crypto-friendly jurisdictions.
• Legal frameworks may lag behind, slowing broader adoption.

Model 5: Fully On-Chain

• In this fully decentralized model, both the asset and its ownership exist solely on the blockchain. All transactions, governance, and rights are managed through smart contracts, without any off-chain involvement. Decentralized finance (DeFi) platforms like Uniswap are prime examples, where liquidity pools and ownership of assets are fully automated.
• Benefits:
• Complete automation, removing intermediaries and reducing transaction costs.
• Increased transparency and security due to blockchain’s immutable nature.
• Challenges:
• Regulatory hurdles, especially in regions where fully decentralized systems are not recognized.
• Increased exposure to cybersecurity risks like smart contract vulnerabilities.

2. Applications Across Industries

Tokenization is already reshaping a variety of industries. Let’s explore its transformative potential across several sectors:

Real Estate

• Tokenization is democratizing real estate investments by fractionalizing high-value properties and allowing retail investors to own shares of these assets. Platforms tokenize residential and commercial properties, offering a more liquid market for traditionally illiquid assets.
• Example: Investors can now purchase small portions of real estate, increasing accessibility and liquidity while reducing the complexity of traditional real estate transactions.

Energy

• Tokenizing renewable energy projects enables individuals to invest in green energy infrastructure like solar or wind farms. Projects tokenize ownership, making it easier for retail investors to contribute to the development of renewable energy sources.
• Example: A wind farm can issue tokens representing ownership shares, allowing smaller investors to fund renewable energy projects while earning returns from energy production.

Intellectual Property (IP)

• Intellectual property tokenization simplifies royalty distribution and ownership transfers, reducing the need for intermediaries and improving transparency. Artists and creators can monetize their IP by tokenizing copyrights, patents, or even creative works.
• Example: Musicians can tokenize their songs, receiving royalties directly through smart contracts, ensuring transparent and automated payments to all stakeholders.

Finance

• Financial institutions are already embracing tokenized debt and equity instruments. Tokenizing bonds reduces the cost and complexity of issuance while making these instruments accessible to a broader range of investors.
• Example: A bank issued a $15 million tokenized bond, simplifying the issuance process and allowing smaller investors to participate with fractional ownership.

3. Erable°’s Position in the Market

Erable° is uniquely positioned to cater to businesses and investors at different stages of tokenization. With its flexible offerings, erable° operates across multiple models, from on-chain representation to more integrated on-chain solutions.

Currently, erable° focuses on Model 2 and Model 3 tokenization, allowing businesses to tokenize assets while relying on traditional legal structures for ownership enforcement. For example, erable°’s revenue-sharing agreement tokenization platform enables fractional ownership, providing liquidity and reducing barriers to entry for smaller investors.

Future Vision:

As regulatory frameworks for tokenization become clearer, erable° plans to expand into fully on-chain models, offering automated governance and seamless compliance through smart contracts. This evolution will allow businesses to harness the full potential of blockchain while reducing operational costs and increasing transparency.

Conclusion

Tokenization is redefining industries by offering more efficient, transparent, and accessible ways to own and manage assets. From traditional finance to fully on-chain models, tokenization provides a spectrum of possibilities, allowing businesses to choose the model that best fits their needs. As regulatory clarity improves and technology evolves, the shift towards more decentralized and automated systems will accelerate.

Join the conversation — follow our blog and social channels to stay updated on the latest in RWA tokenization and impact investing.

• Follow us on X: https://x.com/erableofficial
• Join our Discord: https://discord.gg/erabledeg-897392916081831966